Creditable

Best Life Insurance Companies (2026)

Find the best life insurance policies for your family's financial security, from term to whole life coverage.

Insurance CompanyJD Power ScoreAM Best RatingAvg Annual CostGet Quote
4/5 Creditable Score

652 out of 1,000

A+ (Superior)

$320/yr (20-yr term, $500K, healthy 30-yr-old est. — among the most competitive)

Get a Quote
On Pacific Life's secure site
4/5 Creditable Score

650 out of 1,000

A+ (Superior)

$361/yr avg annual premium (below industry avg of $377)

Get a Quote
On Prudential's secure site
4.5/5 Creditable Score

707 out of 1,000

A+ (Superior)

$353/yr avg annual premium (below industry avg of $377)

Get a Quote
On Mutual of Omaha's secure site
3.5/5 Creditable Score

Not rated

A+ (Superior)

$180–$864/year

Get a Quote
On Ethos's secure site
4.5/5 Creditable Score

679 out of 1,000

A++ (Superior)

$1,020–$8,400/year

Get a Quote
On Guardian Life's secure site
3.5/5 Creditable Score

Not rated

A (Excellent)

$160–$1,500/year

Get a Quote
On Banner Life's secure site
4.5/5 Creditable Score

671 out of 1,000

A++ (Superior)

$370/yr (20-yr term, $500K, healthy 30-yr-old) | ~$4,200/yr (whole life, $500K, 30-yr-old)

Get a Quote
On MassMutual's secure site
4.5/5 Creditable Score

656 out of 1,000

A++ (Superior)

$1,080–$9,000/year

Get a Quote
On New York Life's secure site
4/5 Creditable Score

651 out of 1,000

A+ (Superior)

$250–$8,600/year

Get a Quote
On Penn Mutual's secure site
3.5/5 Creditable Score

600 out of 1,000

A+ (Superior)

$200–$6,000/year

Get a Quote
On Protective's secure site
4.5/5 Creditable Score

677 out of 1,000

A++ (Superior)

$1,200–$9,600/year

Get a Quote
On Northwestern Mutual's secure site
Pacific LifeGet a Quote

On Pacific Life's secure site

4/5 Creditable Score

JD Power Score

652 out of 1,000

AM Best Rating

A+ (Superior)

Avg Annual Cost

$320/yr (20-yr term, $500K, healthy 30-yr-old est. — among the most competitive)

Coverage Options

Term, Indexed Universal, Variable Universal | Coverage: Very Good

Underwriting:Lenient on BP, cholesterol & mild obesity

Why We Like It

  • Highly competitive term life premiums
  • Lenient underwriting helps more applicants qualify for preferred rates
  • Innovative indexed universal life product lineup

Where It Falls Short

  • No traditional whole life insurance offered
  • Not ranked by J.D. Power; lesser-known brand than mutual giants

Pro Tip

Buy life insurance when you're young and healthy — premiums are significantly lower in your 20s and 30s and lock in for the duration of a term policy.

PrudentialGet a Quote

On Prudential's secure site

4/5 Creditable Score

JD Power Score

650 out of 1,000

AM Best Rating

A+ (Superior)

Avg Annual Cost

$361/yr avg annual premium (below industry avg of $377)

Coverage Options

Term, Whole, Universal, Indexed Universal, Variable Universal, Survivorship | Coverage: Excellent

Health Flexibility:Competitive rates for pre-existing conditions

Why We Like It

  • One of the broadest life insurance product suites available
  • More accessible to applicants with complex health backgrounds
  • Premiums below industry average

Where It Falls Short

  • Customer satisfaction doesn't reach top-tier competitors
  • Online experience can be unintuitive for first-time buyers

Mutual of OmahaGet a Quote

On Mutual of Omaha's secure site

4.5/5 Creditable Score

JD Power Score

707 out of 1,000

AM Best Rating

A+ (Superior)

Avg Annual Cost

$353/yr avg annual premium (below industry avg of $377)

Coverage Options

Term, Whole, Universal, Children's Whole Life, Guaranteed Issue, Accidental Death | Coverage: Very Good

J.D. Power Ranking:#1 in 2025 Life Insurance Study

Why We Like It

  • Ranked #1 in J.D. Power 2025 customer satisfaction
  • More generous guaranteed issue terms than industry standard
  • Below-average premiums at $353/yr vs $377 industry avg

Where It Falls Short

  • No variable universal life; limited high face-amount term options
  • Digital tools and online quoting lag behind top competitors

Pro Tip

A common rule of thumb is to get coverage equal to 10–12x your annual income, but factor in your mortgage, debts, and dependents for a more accurate number.

EthosGet a Quote

On Ethos's secure site

3.5/5 Creditable Score

JD Power Score

Not rated

AM Best Rating

A+ (Superior)

Avg Annual Cost

$180–$864/year

Coverage Options

Term Life

Medical Exam:Not required for most applicants

Why We Like It

  • No medical exam required for most applicants
  • Simple, fully online application process
  • Fast approval turnaround

Where It Falls Short

  • Limited to term life — no whole or universal life options
  • Newer company with a shorter track record

Guardian LifeGet a Quote

On Guardian Life's secure site

4.5/5 Creditable Score

JD Power Score

679 out of 1,000

AM Best Rating

A++ (Superior)

Avg Annual Cost

$1,020–$8,400/year

Coverage Options

Whole Life, Universal Life, Term Life, Variable Life

Coverage Limits:$100,000 to $25 million+

Why We Like It

  • A++ (Superior) AM Best financial strength rating
  • Flexible policy options across all life insurance types
  • Available in all 50 states

Where It Falls Short

  • Higher premiums for permanent life insurance products
  • Limited online self-service tools vs. newer insurers

Pro Tip

Term life insurance is the most affordable option for most families — whole life policies cost significantly more and are only worth it in specific financial situations.

Banner LifeGet a Quote

On Banner Life's secure site

3.5/5 Creditable Score

JD Power Score

Not rated

AM Best Rating

A (Excellent)

Avg Annual Cost

$160–$1,500/year

Coverage Options

Term Life

Pricing Edge:Among lowest rates for healthy applicants

Why We Like It

  • Highly competitive rates for healthy individuals
  • Simple, straightforward term coverage
  • Easy online quote process

Where It Falls Short

  • Not ideal for those with health issues
  • No whole life or universal life products

MassMutualGet a Quote

On MassMutual's secure site

4.5/5 Creditable Score

JD Power Score

671 out of 1,000

AM Best Rating

A++ (Superior)

Avg Annual Cost

$370/yr (20-yr term, $500K, healthy 30-yr-old) | ~$4,200/yr (whole life, $500K, 30-yr-old)

Coverage Options

Term, Whole, Universal, Variable

Cash Value Growth:Strong whole life dividend history

Why We Like It

  • A++ AM Best rating signals exceptional financial strength
  • Multiple policy types suit diverse coverage needs
  • Strong cash value accumulation on whole life policies

Where It Falls Short

  • Whole life premiums (~$4,200/yr) are significantly higher than term
  • May not be the most budget-friendly option for whole life buyers

New York LifeGet a Quote

On New York Life's secure site

4.5/5 Creditable Score

JD Power Score

656 out of 1,000

AM Best Rating

A++ (Superior)

Avg Annual Cost

$1,080–$9,000/year

Coverage Options

Whole Life, Universal Life, Term Life, Variable Life

Coverage Limits:$100,000 to $50M+

Why We Like It

  • Highest financial strength ratings from all 4 major agencies
  • 180+ years of industry trust as largest mutual insurer
  • Diverse portfolio: Whole, Term, Universal & Variable Life

Where It Falls Short

  • Premiums higher than term-only alternatives
  • Large policies may require a medical exam

Penn MutualGet a Quote

On Penn Mutual's secure site

4/5 Creditable Score

JD Power Score

651 out of 1,000

AM Best Rating

A+ (Superior)

Avg Annual Cost

$250–$8,600/year

Coverage Options

Whole Life, Term Life

Dividend History:Paid every year since 1847

Why We Like It

  • Uninterrupted dividend payments since before the Civil War
  • Strong long-term financial stability and heritage
  • Competitive term life rates nationwide

Where It Falls Short

  • Less recognized brand compared to industry giants
  • Limited online tools and digital self-service options

ProtectiveGet a Quote

On Protective's secure site

3.5/5 Creditable Score

JD Power Score

600 out of 1,000

AM Best Rating

A+ (Superior)

Avg Annual Cost

$200–$6,000/year

Coverage Options

Term Life, Whole Life, Universal Life

Coverage Types:Term, Whole & Universal Life

Why We Like It

  • Available nationwide across all 50 states
  • Broad range of life insurance products
  • Competitive pricing for term and permanent coverage

Where It Falls Short

  • Customer service quality can be inconsistent
  • Limited third-party review data available

Northwestern MutualGet a Quote

On Northwestern Mutual's secure site

4.5/5 Creditable Score

JD Power Score

677 out of 1,000

AM Best Rating

A++ (Superior)

Avg Annual Cost

$1,200–$9,600/year

Coverage Options

Whole Life, Universal Life, Variable Universal Life, Term Life

Coverage Limits:$250,000 to $10 million+

Why We Like It

  • A++ AM Best rating signals exceptional financial strength
  • Dedicated personal advisor support throughout policy lifecycle
  • Flexible options including whole, universal, variable & term life

Where It Falls Short

  • Higher premiums compared to term life alternatives
  • Complex product range may require advisor consultation

Finding the Best Life Insurance

What Are Life Insurance Policies?

Life insurance is a contract between you and an insurance company. You pay a regular premium — monthly or annually — and in exchange, the insurer pays a lump sum to your chosen beneficiaries when you die. That payout is called the death benefit, and it's typically tax-free for the people who receive it. There are two main types to understand. Term life insurance covers you for a set period, usually 10, 20, or 30 years, and pays out only if you die during that window. Whole life insurance covers you permanently and builds a cash value over time that you can borrow against. Term policies are simpler and much cheaper — a healthy 35-year-old can often get $500,000 of term coverage for under $30 a month. Whole life costs significantly more but serves different financial planning purposes. Most people start by asking how much coverage they need, and a common rule of thumb is 10 to 12 times your annual income.

Why Do People Use Life Insurance?

The most straightforward reason is income replacement. If you have a partner, children, or anyone who depends on your paycheck, life insurance ensures they won't face financial collapse if you die unexpectedly. A $500,000 death benefit invested conservatively could generate roughly $20,000 a year in income — enough to cover essentials while a family rebuilds. Beyond that, people use life insurance to pay off a mortgage so a surviving spouse isn't forced to sell the family home. Parents of young children often buy coverage specifically to fund future college costs. Business owners use it to protect their companies through buy-sell agreements, ensuring a co-owner can buy out their share without forcing a fire sale. Some people use permanent life insurance as part of an estate planning strategy, passing wealth to the next generation efficiently. Life insurance isn't just for breadwinners either — the loss of a stay-at-home parent creates real financial costs like childcare that a surviving spouse suddenly has to cover alone.

What to Consider When Choosing Life Insurance

Start with coverage amount, then look hard at the term length. A 20-year-old with no dependents needs a very different policy than a 40-year-old with a mortgage and three kids. Match your term to your biggest financial obligation — if your mortgage has 25 years left, a 25-year policy makes sense. Price matters, but the cheapest option isn't always the smartest. Check the insurer's financial strength rating from agencies like AM Best; you want an A-rated company or better, since you're trusting them to pay a claim decades from now. Pay close attention to how policies handle pre-existing conditions. Some insurers are more lenient than others about conditions like well-managed diabetes or high blood pressure, which directly affects your premium. Riders are optional add-ons worth knowing about — a waiver of premium rider keeps your coverage active if you become disabled and can't pay. Avoid buying more whole life than you need just because an agent pushes it; most people get better value from term coverage combined with separate investments.

How to Get the Most Out of Life Insurance

Once you have a policy, keep it active — a lapsed policy pays nothing. Set up autopay so a missed payment doesn't accidentally cancel years of coverage. Review your beneficiary designations every few years or after major life events like marriage, divorce, or having children. An outdated beneficiary form can send the death benefit to the wrong person, and it overrides even a will. If you bought term life and your health has significantly improved since then — maybe you quit smoking or lost substantial weight — it's worth shopping again. Smokers pay roughly two to three times more than non-smokers, so quitting and getting reclassified can cut your premiums dramatically. If you have a whole life policy with accumulated cash value, understand the rules before borrowing against it; unpaid loans reduce the death benefit. Finally, store your policy documents somewhere your family can find them and make sure at least one trusted person knows the policy exists. A death benefit no one claims helps no one.